Open Nav
Show Navigation
Show Menu
FANTASY FOOTBALL NEWS

Numbers Not There Yet, But Michael Penix Jr. Plays Well

By Matt Schauf | Updated on Mon, 30 Dec 2024, 3:15 PM EST
Michael Penix Jr. Headshot

Falcons QB Michael Penix Jr. posted modest numbers in Sunday night's loss to the Commanders. He finished with 223 yards, 1 TD, and 1 INT on 19-of-35 passing. That's 54.3% completions and 6.4 yards per attempt against a Washington defense that entered the game ranked just 20th in pass DVOA. But Penix did pilot a scoring drive late in the fourth quarter to tie the game and then helped set up what would have been the game-winning FG attempt at the end of regulation (which fell short).

What They're Saying

HC Raheem Morris: "I love the kid. I love the kid’s fight. I love the kid’s desire. I mean, anybody that can go out there and stand in the face of adversity and throw that strike like he threw to Kyle Pitts to give us an opportunity to win that football game. That’s what it’s about. … He represents everything that’s good about us."

2024 Fantasy Football Impact

Penix has showed some good things through two starts.

Pitts had his best fantasy outing (4-44-1 on 5 targets) since Week 8 on Sunday. And WR Drake London (7-106) reached 100 yards for just the second time all year.

But the rookie QB has also come up short of 230 yards and totaled 1 TD pass against two below-average defenses.

That makes him a weak fantasy bet for the Week 18 home date with Carolina.

2025 Impact

Penix will be interesting as a best-ball stack with Drake London and/or Darnell Mooney -- as long as the market doesn't overvalue him.

If we can get Penix anywhere from about QB18 down in best ball ADP, he'll be worth some shots.

Dynasty Impact

It's pretty clear that Morris has been pleased with Penix's performance through two games. And Atlanta clearly drafted him to be the QB for the foreseeable future.

Penix will open next season as Atlanta's starter, with an attractive supporting cast of skill-position players and an offense that's likely to lean back toward the pass after going run-heavy late this season to counter Kirk Cousins' decline.

The QB also carries the limitation of not being a dual-threat, though. That limits the fantasy upside.

Penix carries Tua Tagovailoa-type fantasy upside. Expect spike-week potential but also a scoring average outside the position's top 12.

That could be enough to make Penix a buyable dynasty asset this offseason. But his early ascension to the starting job has likely boosted his stock vs. where it was a month or two ago.

Just don't overspend if you pursue him.

Other Winners & Losers

London's a bit easier to trust for Week 18 in PPR leagues after going 5-59 on 8 targets and 7-106 on 13 targets in Penix's first two starts.

Pitts has still given us more bad than good this season.

Mooney followed a solid game vs. the Giants (5-82 on 6 targets) with a weak outing at Washington (2-37 on 5 targets). He looks like a fantasy WR4 for Week 18.

Matt Schauf Author Image
Matt Schauf, Editor
Matt has earned two Fantasy Pros accuracy awards for IDP rankings and won thousands of dollars as a player across best ball, dynasty, and high-stakes fantasy formats. He has been creating fantasy football content for more than 20 years, with work featured by Sporting News, Rotoworld, Athlon, Sirius XM, and others. He's been with Draft Sharks since 2011.
Video: Free Agent Moves That Matter

Video: Free Agent Moves That Matter

6 hours ago

Is Najee Harris about to light it up? Should you still avoid Javonte Williams? We're sorting through the early free agent moves in search of fantasy football value ...

Read More »
Shedeur Sanders Dynasty Value: Film Doesn't Lie

Shedeur Sanders Dynasty Value: Film Doesn't Lie

7 hours ago

Shedeur Sanders has been heralded as a top QB prospect, but his film reveals his true potential. Is he a future fantasy QB1 -- or are there MAJOR red flags to worry about?

Read More »
Cam Skattebo Dynasty Value: Overhyped or Underappreciated?

Cam Skattebo Dynasty Value: Overhyped or Underappreciated?

12:02pm EDT 3/11/25

Skattebo exits college after a highly productive 2024. But will his game translate to the NFL? Let’s examine the details and assess Skattebo's dynasty value.

Read More »
Get Instant Access to the Draft War Room & Much MoreWhy Wouldn't You Invest $35 To Win Your League?
Select Billing Option:
Semi-annually
Monthly
Save 60% by paying semi-annually!
Redraft Leagues, Unlimited
$6$16
Per month , billed semi-annually Question

IncludedUnlimited Live-Draft SyncQuestionQuestion
IncludedDraft War RoomQuestionQuestion
IncludedMock Draft TrainerQuestionQuestion
IncludedFree Agent FinderQuestionQuestion
IncludedSit-Start Team GuideQuestionQuestion
IncludedTrade NavigatorQuestionQuestion
Add Personalized Advice
$16$44
Per month , billed semi-annually Question

Get personalized advice all season:
  • Draft questions
  • Lineup decisions
  • Trade and Waiver Wire advice
  • Really, any fantasy football advice you need
Via email... straight from our fantasy analysts to you!
Compare Plans »
THE 2025 ROOKIE GUIDE IS HERE! UPDATED POST-DRAFT
Trade Values • Model Scores • Analytics & More