Open Nav
Show Navigation
Show Menu
FANTASY FOOTBALL NEWS

J.J. McCarthy to Miss Entire Rookie Season

By Matt Schauf | Updated on Wed, 14 Aug 2024, 2:16 PM EDT
J.J. McCarthy Headshot

The Vikings announced Wednesday that QB J.J. McCarthy will miss the entire 2024 season. Surgery on the meniscus in the rookie's right knee revealed that he needed a full repair.

What They're Saying

ESPN's Adam Schefter: "While the Vikings are disappointed, they 'strongly believe he will come back better and have a long, successful NFL career,' as one team official said."

2024 Fantasy Football Impact

Offseason and camp buzz already had Sam Darnold expected to open the regular season as Minnesota's starter. History, however, pointed to McCarthy likely stepping in at some point.

Instead, Darnold figures to run the offense until he gets hurt or struggles to the point of getting pulled.

Nick Mullens and Jaren Hall currently back him up, now that McCarthy's out. They played poorly enough after Kirk Cousins' 2023 injury that the Vikings paid Darnold $10 million.

Darnold started just seven total games over the past two years and has never started more than 13 in a season. His career INT rate (3.1%) remains too near his career TD rate (3.5%).

But he also gets the best set of receivers he's had since entering the NFL -- especially Justin Jefferson.

Don't expect Darnold to make much fantasy impact outside of 2-QB and superflex leagues. We'll see if he can surprise at that level.

Dynasty Impact

You won't find McCarthy moving much in our dynasty rankings.

If you selected him in either your rookie draft or startup draft, then you shouldn't have been doing so for his 2024 outlook.

This should be a learning year for the rookie. He now simply must do so without the chance to take the field.

Other Winners & Losers

It's tough to call any of the Vikings pass catchers losers for the McCarthy injury, given that we don't know when/if McCarthy would have stepped in anyway.

If you're now more worried about Jefferson, remember that he delivered WR1 production over the final four games of last season with Nick Mullens flinging passes.

Rankings Movement

Darnold now becomes a viable late QB2 or upside QB3 in our superflex rankings.

Mullens got those aforementioned four games with a healthy Jefferson late last season and finished three of them among the top 14. That included a QB5 finish in Week 18.

Don't expect a significant shift for Jefferson or the other Minnesota pass catchers in our keeper rankings.

Projected ADP Movement

Watch for this news to nudge Jefferson's ADP down in Round 1 -- and consider taking advantage if it does.

DFS Impact

Darnold will be especially interesting in early-season DFS contests. A road trip against the Giants in Week 1 makes him a potentially low-owned cheap starter option right away.

Injury History: New Developments & Historical Context

The full meniscus repair for McCarthy shouldn't create any long-term concern. Players typically make a full recovery from meniscus injuries.

Matt Schauf Author Image
Matt Schauf, Editor
Matt has earned two Fantasy Pros accuracy awards for IDP rankings and won thousands of dollars as a player across best ball, dynasty, and high-stakes fantasy formats. He has been creating fantasy football content for more than 20 years, with work featured by Sporting News, Rotoworld, Athlon, Sirius XM, and others. He's been with Draft Sharks since 2011.
What is Wrong with Jaylen Waddle?

What is Wrong with Jaylen Waddle?

1 hour ago

Jaylen Waddle has disappointed dynasty managers this season. But what is the problem? Can it be fixed? Let's dive into the film to see if there is any hope.

Read More »
Fantasy Football Matchups That Matter - Week 12

Fantasy Football Matchups That Matter - Week 12

4 hours ago

A quick look at the most important matchup data to consider when making Week 12 start/sit decisions, including implied points, projected plays, WR/CB matchups, and adjusted fantasy points allowed.

Read More »
Fantasy Football Trade Targets, Sells, and Holds – Week 12

Fantasy Football Trade Targets, Sells, and Holds – Week 12

17 hours ago

J.K. Dobbins is just one of four fresh RBs to hit this week's fantasy football trade targets. Let's discuss what you should do with him and a host of others.

Read More »
Compare Plans » Compare Plans »
THE 2024 ROOKIE GUIDE IS HERE! UPDATED POST-DRAFT
Trade Values • Model Scores • Analytics • Sleepers • Busts & More