Open Nav
Show Navigation
Show Menu
FANTASY FOOTBALL NEWS

J.J. McCarthy to Undergo Knee Surgery After Torn Meniscus

By Shane Hallam | Updated on Tue, Aug 13 2024 4:47 PM UTC
J.J. McCarthy Headshot

Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy will underdog knee surgery after complaining about knee soreness. After an MRI, it was revealed that he has a torn meniscus in his right knee. The amount of time he will miss is currently unknown, but we will update when more information is available.

What They're Saying

Adam Schefter from ESPN: "Vikings rookie first-round pick J.J. McCarthy is expected to be undergo knee surgery that will determine how much time he will be sidelined. McCarthy complained about knee soreness over the weekend, and underwent an MRI on Monday night."

Vikings HC Kevin O'Connell: "As far as the timeline of the injury, that will be something determined during the procedure" whether it's a cleanup or full repair.

2024 Fantasy Football Impact

McCarthy had a solid preseason debut throwing for 188 yards, two TDs and an interception. He appeared to be progressing well in his play and there was potential for him to start early.

McCarthy was in a QB competition to be the Vikings starter for Week 1 with QB Sam Darnold. It appeared that Darnold would win the job, but the leash was expected to be short.

Knee surgery puts all of this in flux as McCarthy is likely to be sidelined at least for the rest of the preseason, if not longer. His ability to compete for the starting job is likely gone with a focus on recovery instead.

We will update with the severity and potential time missed with the knee injury when it is reported.

Shane Hallam Author Image
Shane Hallam, Writer
Shane has over 20 years of experience creating content and playing every fantasy football format including redraft, dynasty, devy, C2C, IDP, and more. He is a multi-year winner of $500 dynasty leagues on the FFPC and utilizes deep film and scheme study to enhance his fantasy performance.
Premium Content Premium ContentJaxson Dart Dynasty Value: Big Arm, Bigger Question Marks

Jaxson Dart Dynasty Value: Big Arm, Bigger Question Marks

0 seconds

QB Jaxson Dart has the arm strength and rushing upside to be a fantasy difference maker. But will his experience be enough to make him a consistent NFL starter?

Read More »
Video: Top QB Prospects of 2025

Video: Top QB Prospects of 2025

4 hours ago

Cam Ward looks like the No. 1 pick -- but is that enough to make him a high-value superflex asset? Should you target or pass on Jaxson Dart and Shedeur Sanders in your dynasty rookie draft? Let's talk through the top prospects PLUS three sleepers.

Read More »
Ollie Gordon Dynasty Value: Buyer Beware, But Don’t Ignore the Ceiling

Ollie Gordon Dynasty Value: Buyer Beware, But Don’t Ignore the Ceiling

5 hours ago

Ollie Gordon’s resume features a huge 2023 season and highlight-reel runs — but also a rocky 2024 campaign, underwhelming Combine, and off-field concerns. Is he a future fantasy workhorse or just another big back who peaked in college?

Read More »
Get Instant Access to the Draft War Room & Much MoreWhy Wouldn't You Invest $28 To Win Your League?
Select Billing Option:
Semi-annually
Monthly
Save 60% by paying semi-annually!
Redraft Leagues, Unlimited
$6$16
Per month , billed semi-annually Question

IncludedUnlimited Live-Draft SyncQuestionQuestion
IncludedDraft War RoomQuestionQuestion
IncludedMock Draft TrainerQuestionQuestion
IncludedFree Agent FinderQuestionQuestion
IncludedSit-Start Team GuideQuestionQuestion
IncludedTrade NavigatorQuestionQuestion
Add Personalized Advice
$16$44
Per month , billed semi-annually Question

Get personalized advice all season:
  • Draft questions
  • Lineup decisions
  • Trade and Waiver Wire advice
  • Really, any fantasy football advice you need
Via email... straight from our fantasy analysts to you!
Compare Plans »
THE 2025 ROOKIE GUIDE (V2) IS UPDATED!
100 Prospects • Mock Drafts • Trade Values • Model Scores • Analytics & More